| 34 | Butz, Kyle | 13 | Atlanta Braves | Jason Hayward | Baby Got Back / Eminem | Pizza | |
| 2 | Callihan, Rory | 13 | Pirates / Tampa Rays | Jason Kendall | Lil Wayne | Noodles | Rooster |
| 11 | Canter, Caleb | | | | | | |
| 16 | Flesher, Nick | | | | | | |
| 13 | Gremlin, Mitch | | | | | | |
| 99 | Hiles, Nate | | | | | | |
| 32 | Hillard, Genesis | 14 | Boston Red Sox | Josh Hamilton | Black & Yellow / Drake | Ribs | G |
| 22 | Shutrump, Johnny | 14 | Cleveland Indians | Omar Visquel | 99 Problems / Jay Z | Wings | Shoelace |
| 7 | Smith, Alex | 14 | Cincinnati Reds | Alex Rodriquez | I'm so Hood by DJ Khaled | Cheeseburger | |
| 3 | Spikes, Trent | | | | | | |
| 12 | Tomlinson, Scott | | | | | | |
| 1 | Weigel, Andrew | 14 | Cincinnati Reds | Brandon Phillips | Bottoms UP | Everything | Weigs |
| 44 | Williams, Nigel | 14 | Phillies | Chase Uttley | I'm Back / T.I. | Pepperoni Pizza | Hammer |
|
